← back to the directory
AS-011 Discount department store · USA 2002

Ames — The Small-Town Discounter That Bought Its Way Broke

overexpansionliquidated2000s
Lifespan
1958–2002 · 44 yrs
Peak Stores
~450+ (1999, post-Hills)
Killed By
overexpansion (Hills) + Walmart
Status
Liquidated

Summary

Ames Department Stores was the discounter that small-town New England shopped at when a Walmart was still an hour's drive away, and on August 14, 2002 it announced it would close every one of its remaining 327 stores. Founded in 1958 in Southbridge, Massachusetts by the brothers Milton, Irving, and Herbert Gilman — who started in a corner of the old Ames Worsted Textile mill — it grew into the fourth-largest discount retailer in the United States, behind only Walmart, Kmart, and Target, with roughly 450 stores across some 20 states and annual sales above $4 billion. Its niche was geographic: the rural and small-town Northeast, the towns too small to interest the giants, where Ames was often the only real general-merchandise store for miles.

What killed Ames was, in the end, a single deal. The chain had already survived one near-death experience — a 1990 bankruptcy, triggered partly by a reckless store-credit policy, from which it emerged leaner in 1992 and profitable by 1993. Then, in November 1998, it agreed to swallow the 155-store Hills Department Stores chain in a transaction valued at about $330 million including assumed debt, a deal that lifted Ames from roughly 300 stores to about 456 in a matter of months. The strategic logic was defensive — get bigger before Walmart arrived — but the financing was punishing, and converting the Hills stores cost another $170 million on top.

The debt from Hills met the tightening credit markets of 2001 at exactly the wrong moment, and the second-largest US discounter to ever liquidate found its suppliers tightening terms and slowing shipments. Ames filed for Chapter 11 again in August 2001, fought for a year, and on August 14, 2002 converted the reorganization to a Chapter 7 liquidation. CEO Joseph Ettore called it "a wrenching decision, but the right course." The going-out-of-business sales ran about ten weeks. Roughly 22,000 employees lost their jobs, and a great many small towns lost the only department store they had.

Timeline

1958
A discounter in a textile mill
The Gilman brothers — Milton, Irving, and Herbert — open the first Ames in Southbridge, Massachusetts, in a corner of the family's Ames Worsted Textile Company.
1960s–1980s
Filling the empty map
Ames expands across rural and small-town New England and the Mid-Atlantic, deliberately serving markets too small for the national chains, often as the only general-merchandise store in town.
1988
The Zayre gamble
Ames buys the larger Zayre discount chain, nearly doubling its size overnight — an early taste of growth by acquisition that strained the company.
April 1990
First bankruptcy
Burdened by the Zayre debt and a loose store-credit policy that handed cards to almost anyone, Ames files for Chapter 11 and closes hundreds of weaker stores.
December 1992
Out of Chapter 11
Ames emerges from bankruptcy a smaller, focused regional discounter and returns to profitability by 1993.
November 1998
The Hills deal
Ames agrees to acquire the 155-store Hills Department Stores chain in a transaction valued at about $330 million including debt, vaulting its count toward 456 stores.
March 1999
The deal closes
The Hills acquisition is consummated; Ames plans to spend roughly $170 million converting and reopening the Hills stores under its own banner.
2000
Fourth-largest — and overextended
Ames is now the nation's fourth-largest discount retailer with sales above $4 billion, but the integration falters and the debt bites.
August 2001
Second bankruptcy
After closing dozens more stores, Ames files for Chapter 11 again, citing soft sales and the tightening credit markets.
August 14, 2002
Liquidation
Ames converts to Chapter 7 and announces the closure of all 327 remaining stores; about 22,000 employees lose their jobs.
Late 2002
Lights out
The going-out-of-business sales conclude after roughly ten weeks, ending 44 years and emptying anchor space across the small-town Northeast.

The Store That Filled the Empty Map

Ames understood something its bigger rivals took decades to learn: there was money in the towns nobody else wanted. While Kmart chased the suburbs and the regional malls, the Gilmans planted Ames stores in the small New England and Mid-Atlantic towns where the population could not support a full mall but could absolutely support one well-run discount store. In a great many of those places, Ames was not a choice among several stores — it was the store, the one place to buy a winter coat, a lawn chair, a child's bicycle, and a box of nails without driving to the next county. That made it beloved in a way the giants rarely were, and for a long stretch it made it profitable.

The strategy had a built-in vulnerability, though, which was that it depended on the giants staying away. As long as the nearest Walmart was an hour's drive, Ames owned its towns. The chain's history was therefore a long race against the map: a race to lock in the small markets and build enough scale to matter before the discounters with deeper pockets and lower costs arrived. Ames ran that race partly by acquisition, and acquisition is a fast way to add stores and a fast way to add debt. The 1988 purchase of Zayre nearly doubled the company and helped push it into its first bankruptcy in 1990 — a rehearsal, it turned out, for the larger mistake to come.

The Hills That Buried It

Coming out of bankruptcy in 1992, Ames was disciplined, focused, and — for a few years — exactly the right size. Then it decided to get much bigger, very fast, for a defensible reason and at an indefensible price. In November 1998 it agreed to acquire Hills Department Stores, a 155-store discount chain based in Canton, Massachusetts, in a deal valued at roughly $330 million including the assumption of Hills's debt. The transaction, which closed in March 1999, lifted Ames from about 301 stores to roughly 456 and made it the fourth-largest discounter in the country. The thinking was sound on a slide: more stores meant more buying power, more distribution efficiency, and a bigger moat against the approaching Walmart.

The execution was where it came apart. Converting 155 Hills stores into Ames stores — closing them briefly, remodeling, reopening — cost an additional $170 million, and the combined company carried far more debt than the focused regional chain had. Worse, the two banners' customers and merchandising did not blend as cleanly as the spreadsheet promised; the disruption of the conversions hurt sales at precisely the moment Ames needed every dollar to service the new debt. A retailer that had spent the 1990s carefully rebuilding had, in a single deal, re-leveraged itself just as its industry was about to consolidate violently around the lowest-cost operator.

Then the timing turned cruel. The credit markets tightened sharply in 2001, and a heavily indebted retailer is at the mercy of its suppliers' nerve. As vendors grew wary, they shortened payment terms and slowed shipments — which thinned the shelves, which depressed sales, which alarmed the vendors further. Ames filed for Chapter 11 again in August 2001 and spent a year trying to engineer a survival. Meanwhile Walmart, which had been a distant rumor when Ames staked out its towns, was now opening Supercenters across the Northeast, undercutting Ames on price in the very markets that had been its sanctuary. The moat had been filled in.

The Largest Discount Liquidation of Its Day

On August 14, 2002, Ames gave up. The company converted its Chapter 11 reorganization into a Chapter 7 liquidation and announced that all 327 remaining stores would close. CEO Joseph Ettore framed it plainly: "Continued softness in sales, combined with tightening terms and slower shipments from our suppliers, have reduced our funds availability below critical levels." At the time it was among the largest discount-retail liquidations the United States had seen — 327 stores and roughly 22,000 jobs gone in a single announcement, the bigger-is-safer bet ending in the biggest closure of its kind.

The going-out-of-business sales ran about ten weeks, the familiar liquidation theater of escalating markdowns and stripped fixtures playing out across small-town New England. For the towns themselves, the loss was disproportionate: the death of the only department store for miles left a real hole, and the Ames buildings — too big for most local tenants, too remote for most national ones — sat empty as monuments to a chain that had served the places no one else would.

The Five Factors

01
Growth by acquisition adds stores fast and debt faster
Ames doubled itself with Zayre in 1988 and again leapt with Hills in 1998, and both times the new stores came packaged with new debt and integration cost. A chain that buys scale instead of building it inherits someone else's problems and pays for the privilege; the store count rises on the press release while the balance sheet quietly deteriorates underneath it.
02
A defensive merger can be the thing that kills you
The Hills deal was meant to fortify Ames against Walmart by making it bigger and lower-cost. Instead the $330 million price, the $170 million conversion bill, and the disruption of the integration left Ames weaker and more leveraged precisely when it needed to be nimble. Getting big to survive a stronger competitor is not the same as getting strong.
03
Debt turns a soft year into a fatal one
A debt-free retailer can ride out a bad season; a heavily indebted one cannot, because its suppliers will not let it. When credit tightened in 2001, vendors shortened Ames's terms and slowed shipments, and a chain that needed full shelves to generate the cash to pay its debt got neither. Leverage removes the margin for ordinary misfortune.
04
A niche built on a rival's absence expires when the rival arrives
Ames's whole model depended on Walmart being far away. That was never a durable advantage — only a temporary one, running on the clock of Walmart's expansion plan. When the Supercenters reached the Northeast, the moat evaporated, and a chain that had defined itself by serving the towns no one else wanted found that everyone else now wanted them too.
05
Integration is where mergers actually fail
The Hills logic worked on a slide and failed on the sales floor. Closing, remodeling, and re-bannering 155 stores disrupted the business and confused the customers at the worst possible moment. Acquisitions are won or lost not in the announcement but in the unglamorous, expensive, error-prone work of making two companies behave like one.

Aftermath

The roughly 22,000 people who worked at Ames lost their jobs in the autumn of 2002, many of them in small towns where the store had been one of the larger local employers and where another comparable job was not a short commute away. The pain was concentrated exactly where the chain's strength had been — in the places too small to absorb the loss easily. The real estate told the same story: Ames buildings, sized for a department store and sited in modest markets, were awkward to re-let, and a number of them sat vacant for years, the faded sign-shadow of the old logo still legible on the brick.

The brand simply ended. There was no zombie website, no licensed afterlife, no single nostalgic store kept alive for the tourists — Ames liquidated cleanly and disappeared into the memory of a particular kind of New England childhood. What endures is the lesson, which the discount sector would relearn repeatedly: that the regional discounters of the 1990s — Ames, Caldor, Bradlees, Hills, Jamesway — were not killed one by one by bad luck but were collectively run over by the cost structure of the national giants, and that the ones who tried to bulk up by acquisition mostly just borrowed their way to the front of the line.

Lessons

  1. Buy scale only when you can integrate it: an acquisition that doubles your stores and your debt while disrupting both chains' sales is a wager against your own execution, and execution is where mergers usually lose.
  2. Treat a defensive merger with extra suspicion — the impulse to get big fast because a stronger rival is coming often produces exactly the leveraged, distracted, under-margined company that the rival then finishes off.
  3. Keep debt low if your edge is geographic, because a niche that exists only while a bigger competitor stays away is on a countdown clock, and you will want a clean balance sheet when the clock runs out.
  4. Watch your suppliers' terms as a vital sign: when vendors start shortening terms and slowing shipments, the liquidation has effectively already begun, and a debt-laden retailer has no power to reverse it.
  5. For the small towns that depend on a single anchor: a chain that serves only the markets no one else wants is uniquely fragile, and its closure leaves a hole that no other store is waiting to fill.

References